FEMMES
ARE
OUT
of
fashion.
So
posits
my
friend
Coya,
and
I
wonder
if
she
might
be
right.
When
she
says
“out
of
fashion,”
she
means
that
feminine
lesbians
are
now
being
marginalized
in
a
new
way.
The
gold
standard,
of
course,
has
long
been
butch.
Since
I
came
out
13
years
ago,
most
lesbians
try
to
be
butch,
especially
when
they
first
come
out.
Some
women
were
just
always
tomboys,
and
lesbians
welcome
them
the
way
they
are.
But
even
women
who
love
lace
and
frills
often
try
out
butchness.
Partly
I
think
that’s
because
being
butch,
even
for
a
little
while,
is
a
good
way
to
shake
off
the
many
chains
that
women
wear.
It’s
a
good
way
to
learn
that
you
don’t
have
to
be
vulnerable
to
be
valuable,
that
you
don’t
have
to
be
pretty
to
be
attractive,
that
you
can
be
smart
and
strong
and
loud,
and
women
will
not
only
be
OK
with
that,
but
they’ll
want
to
sleep
with
you.
Also,
short
hair,
a
boyish
way
of
walking,
an
eschewing
of
make-up,
jewelry
and
high
heels,
makes
us
more
recognizable
to
each
other,
and
so
it
is
not
surprising
that
single
lesbians
might
aim
to
proclaim
their
lesbianism
as
loudly
as
possible.
BUT
FOR
THE
first
time
that
Coya
or
I
can
remember,
not
only
don’t
most
younger
lesbians
want
to
be
femmes
—
but
they
don’t
want
to
date
them,
either.
The
butch-femme
dynamic
is
all
but
dead
for
women
under
30.
I’m
not
crying
about
that.
I
myself
always
felt
trapped
when
I
was
the
femme
half
of
a
butch-femme
couple.
It’s
not
easy
being
the
one
who
is
always
expected
to
be
weaker,
more
emotionally
savvy,
less
able
to
protect
herself,
more
easily
moved
to
tears.
It
was
hard
to
keep
my
temper
when
women
called
me
“Bambi”
or
compared
me
to
various
porn
stars
just
because
I
happen
to
be
well
endowed.
These
things
are
cyclical,
of
course.
Another
friend
who
came
of
age
in
the
androgynous
1980s
says
she
was
horrified
by
how
butch-femme
couples
dominate
the
lesbian
scene.
It
seemed
to
her
an
aping
of
heterosexual
conventions,
a
trend
that
bought
into
the
idea
that
only
masculine
people
could
be
paired
with
feminine
ones.
Yet
with
the
demise
of
the
butch-femme
couple
comes
the
general
idea
that
femmes
aren’t
dating
material.
YOUNG
WOMEN
WHO
once
called
themselves
butch
now
call
themselves
tranny
bois,
and
these
tranny
bois
are
mostly
dating
each
other.
This
is
interesting,
and
I
wonder
why.
Are
femmes
not
trangressive
enough
in
our
new
gender
queer
era?
Are
they
not
playful
enough
with
gender
roles?
Are
tranny
bois
and
androgynous
lesbians
worried
that
femmes
are
a
trap
that
would
force
them
into
more
traditional
butch
roles?
Or
is
it
really
that
young
lesbians
are
simply
not
attracted
to
women
who
are
feminine?
Let’s
face
it:
When
it
comes
to
curvy,
feminine
women,
lesbians
may
preach
acceptance.
We
may
pay
lip
service
to
it.
After
all,
we
have
been
acculturated
to
accept
all
body
types,
at
least
theoretically.
We
celebrate
thin
women,
boyish
women,
curvy
women,
chubby
women,
stocky
women,
butch
women,
femme
women,
androgynous
women.
Every
woman’s
body,
every
woman’s
gender
identity,
is
OK
with
us.
Only
it’s
not.
Neither
Coya
nor
I
are
immune
from
this
general
social
pressure.
Coya,
a
self-described
femme,
prefers
boyish
women.
I
tend
to
date
more
androgynous
women
—
usually
women
with
boyish
bodies
who
wear
lipstick,
or
who
slide
easily
between
femme-ish
and
butch-ish.
Think
Alice
on
“The
L
Word.”
Or
really,
any
of
the
women
of
“The
L
Word,”
who
are
too
butch
to
be
femme
and
too
femme
to
be
butch.
We
might
say
that
any
woman’s
body
is
OK
with
us,
but
what
we
say
is
not
who
we
date.
We
might
have
an
aesthetic
that
says
that
curvy
women
are
beautiful,
but
we
are
attracted
to
women
who
don’t
have
curves
or
who
play
them
down.
The
gender
queer
contingent
among
lesbians
are
our
current
taste-makers;
where
they
go,
so
go
we
all.
Femmes,
I’m
sure,
will
come
back
into
fashion
some
day.
But
until
they
do,
I
wonder
if
we
will
continue
to
make
room
for
all
the
ways
we
express
gender.